Boo to Trick or Treat
Is the prospect of handing out sweets under threat of being tricked this Halloween sending a shiver down your spine? , a philosopher with an interest in play and narrative, emailed us to share his concern that trick-or-treat is, in effect, a school for tiny extortionists. Here's what he wrote:
It provides a splendid run-in for anyone wanting to set up a protection racket when he grows up, or even to begin life as a blackmailer. It has been imported from America, no doubt as a result of Spielberg's 'E.T.', and the eagerness of firms to work in their advertisements parasitically on any children's fad.
And in a little monologue we recorded this afternoon, he enlarges upon his concerns:
Well, is Wright right? Or is he a later-day Scrooge crying humbug to the spirit Halloween fun? There are certainly .
And if you are reading this after Halloween, how was trick-or-treat for you? Did you feel extorted or were you happy to pass around the toffee? Are you a parent shuddering at the thought of law-suits and dental bills? Your thoughts welcome.
UPDATE: Hmmm my own experiences last night included pavements covered with smashed eggs and fireworks lobbed like mortars in the general direction of the bus-stop. So I'm in exactly the right frame of mind to read this : an economist at the American Enterprise institute argues, having surveyed a basket of sweetie bags and found most of the content inedible, that the economic cost of Trick-or-Treat is 1.5 billion dollars (that's roughly the amount the author estimates is wasted in disgusting candy usually given away at Halloween). The solution the author identifies is to give money not sweets. Now I may be no economist, but I think there may be significant associated with that scheme - more eggs and fireworks anyone?
UPDATE II: takes a different view in an entertaining post:
As a Constable, I used to enjoy responding to these calls by broadcasting the descriptions given over the radio channel. 鈥淭he informant says the offenders are about 5 ft tall, dressed in a white sheet with chains, one has a bolt through his neck and huge stitches on his forehead and the other has fangs and blood dripping from his chin, over鈥.
In his view the desire to ban trick-or-treating is another example of society making childhood a crime.




Rupert: A Design Classic? Transport for London is considering a new "improved" . are not convinced. Has this been ruined by an overload of information? Also, car sharing for those without a car. But does this idea from make sense?
Marc: Lest We Forget - this year's is clearly more political than in the past. Does that cause a problem? More soon. Oh and if you like facebook -
Chris: One from the kitchen table. Are the shortest recipes in the world? We'll see if they can be long on taste as well as short on detail. UPDATE: Chris says, I'm not sure they are the shortest, (water-boil-egg) surely takes that prize, but they are all less than 140 characters which is tough limit for an entire online cookbook.
George: is about to start in the US. Yahoo is accused of 鈥渁iding and abetting鈥 the torture committed against Chinese dissidents by handing over the names + IP addresses of Wang Xiaoning and Shi Tao - blogger and journalist. We'll debate what responsibilities internet companies have to protect the anonymity of users in the countries in which they operate.
Jenny: I've been speaking to . It's big and ambitious and we hope to hear more from the people behind it all.









Eddie In his first job in radio, Eddie Mair once had to dress up as a giant panda. It's been downhill since then, really.
Rupert is currently making up his mind whether to spend money on an old Italian sports car or get another cat. Unlike other members of the team, he does own a television.
Marc is the number two on the iPM team, a position he has risen to without trace or indeed explanation. When not working at the 蜜芽传媒, Marc likes Bulgarian poetry, whittling wood, restoring sheds and making up random nonsense about himself.
Chris (aka Mr Blog): Chris鈥檚 first radio job was with WGN in Chicago. If you've ever watched Frasier, I was like Ros but without the exciting love life. We don't have a TV but we have more books than bricks in the flat. I own too many microphones..
George also lacks a TV, and it鈥檚 rumoured an iron, but has a rich internal life involving ukeleles, tinkering with things and talking about himself in the third person.
Jenny is the iPM web queen and travels far and wide online in search of stories. She grew up by the sea. She owns lots of red shoes. She has 1 TV and 4 radios, enough said.
Peter sits in meetings all day.